What are the Best Mushrooms To Cook With Steak? (6 of the Best) - Xotic Mushrooms

What are the Best Mushrooms To Cook With Steak? (6 of the Best)

When it comes to enhancing the flavors of a delicious steak dish, there's nothing quite like the umami-rich and earthy taste of mushrooms. 

Whether you are preparing a hearty steak dinner or a succulent grilled steak, mushrooms make the perfect accompaniment to elevate your meal to new heights. 

In this article, we'll explore six of the best mushrooms to cook with steak, each bringing its unique flavors and textures to the table.

From the smoky taste of Shiitake to the woodsy notes of Porcini, these mushrooms are sure to delight your taste buds and elevate your culinary experience.

1. Shiitake Mushrooms

image of Shiitake mushrooms, set in a forest environment to highlight their natural beauty.

Shiitake mushrooms are a standout choice for enhancing the flavor of steak. 

With their smoky taste and umami-rich profile, they beautifully complement the meat's richness. 

To prepare a mouthwatering steak dish, grill the meat to perfection and sauté fresh Shiitake mushrooms separately. 

The earthy and smoky essence of the mushrooms will take your steak to a whole new level of deliciousness. 

Don't worry about overcooking Shiitake mushrooms, as their firm stems ensure they remain perfectly textured and flavorful.

2. Portobello Mushrooms

image of Portobello mushrooms, showcasing their distinctive features and natural setting.

When it comes to pairing mushrooms with steak, Portobellos are a classic choice. 

With a meaty texture and a flavor profile similar to steak, Portobellos add a hearty and satisfying element to your dish. 

These large mushrooms, approximately 6 inches across, require only a few to complement your steak. Consider grilling Portobello mushrooms alongside the steak or marinating them in olive oil and balsamic vinegar for a delightful acidic touch. 

Whether you're a carnivore or a vegan, this pairing is sure to please even the most discerning palates.

3. Cremini Mushroom

image of Cremini mushrooms, highlighting their characteristic texture and earthy colors.

Often referred to as "baby bellas," Cremini mushrooms are young versions of the beloved Portobello mushrooms. 

These brown-hued mushrooms boast a distinctly earthy taste and a firm texture. Sautéing Creminis in a mixture of butter and herbs brings out their robust flavor, making them an ideal side dish for any steak preparation. 

Alternatively, cook them right in the same skillet with the steak for an earthy flavor infusion. With their versatility and rich taste, Cremini mushrooms are an excellent choice to elevate your steak experience.

4. Oyster Mushrooms

image of Oyster mushrooms, featuring their unique fan-like shapes and the natural setting in which they thrive.

Oyster mushrooms are a delightful addition to any steak dish, with their delicate and briny flavor profile. 

Available in various colors such as pale ivory, yellow, pink, or greyish-blue, Oyster mushrooms turn tender and moist when cooked. 

To enjoy their full flavor potential, sauté Oyster mushrooms briefly in olive oil and butter before adding them on top of a grilled steak. 

For an extra burst of flavor, use the same pan you grilled the meat in to infuse the mushrooms with browned pieces for a truly delightful experience.

5. Porcini Mushrooms

image of Porcini mushrooms, capturing their robust form and the natural forest setting they thrive in.

Although not as popular as their counterparts, Portobello or Shiitake mushrooms, Porcini mushrooms should not be underestimated when it comes to pairing with steak. 

With their distinctive woodsy flavor, Porcinis add depth and richness to your dish. Skewer these mushrooms, brush them with olive oil, and grill them alongside your steak for a truly delightful taste. 

Despite their small size, Porcini mushrooms pack a strong nutty flavor and are perfect for absorbing sauces, adding a unique dimension to your steak feast.

6. Morel Mushrooms

image of Morel mushrooms, featuring their distinctive honeycomb texture and natural forest habitat.

Morel mushrooms are a true delicacy and a perfect addition to your special occasion steak dinner. 

While they may be harder to find and slightly more expensive, their exceptional nutty flavor and spongy texture make them worth the investment. 

Sauteed in butter, Morel mushrooms perfectly complement a perfectly-cooked steak, creating a harmonious and luxurious dining experience. Just remember to clean them thoroughly as they grow in the wild and may harbor tiny bugs.

Considerations for Choosing The Right Mushrooms

When selecting mushrooms for your steak dish, there are a few essential considerations to keep in mind. 

  • Look for mushrooms with firm textures and no signs of bruising. Examine the gills underneath the mushroom; tightly placed gills indicate freshness, while separated gills suggest aging. Depending on your preference, opt for mushrooms with tight gills for longer storage or those with loose gills for stronger flavors. 
  • Properly washing the mushrooms is crucial to remove any dirt or bugs that may have latched onto them during harvesting.
  • Freshness: Look for tightly packed gills, as they indicate freshness. If you're planning to store them, this is crucial.
  • Flavor Compatibility: Consider the type of steak and the desired flavor profile.
  • Availability: Seasonal mushrooms like Morels might be harder to find, so plan accordingly.

Final Thoughts

Pairing mushrooms with steak elevates your culinary experience to new heights, enriching the flavors of your favorite cut of meat. 

From the smoky and rich taste of Shiitake to the earthy delight of Cremini, each mushroom brings its unique qualities to enhance your dish. 

The choices are diverse, and experimentation with different varieties and cooking methods will lead you to discover the perfect pairing that suits your taste buds. 

So, the next time you indulge in a delectable steak, don't forget to add a burst of flavor with one of these six best mushrooms. Your taste buds will thank you!

Back to blog